If you look at Mitt Romney’s credentials, you see an uncommon financial success, a traditional conservative family, leadership credibility in both the public and private sector, and the kind of driver’s license vitals that make for a top-notch political candidate. So why can’t he break through to his electorate? He’s is the quintessential conventionally successful Republican candidate. In the 90’s, Mitt Romney would have been the kind of run-away candidate that Republicans were hoping to pit against Obama this year. But this isn’t the 90’s. The social, political, and economic landscape is a post-apocalyptic wasteland of media sensationalism, political partisanship, and ideological radicalism compared to the politically-correct angsty cuteness of the 1990’s.
Romney credentials as the conventional Republican candidate are exactly what’s keeping him from the sought-after position of the “inevitable nominee”. In a broader sense, it’s the Republican Party’s “conventional candidates” that got us to where we are today, so it’s not unthinkable that Romney’s slick good looks, mushy conservatism, and full-to-bursting piggy bank are actually working against him in the current political climate. We’re in an age of Tea Party limited government radicalism and Occupy Wall Street anti-plutocracy protests. We’re in an age of popular unrest and anger against the status quo, and those people that we feel reflect the status quo. Newt Gingrich understands this, which is why he’s putting some serious miles between him and his own Washington “insider-ship” from the 90’s. In fact, he didn’t fit in then either, and he’s actually pointing to that as evidence that he is an outsider, that he doesn’t belong with the Washington elites. It worked in South Carolina, so he sure as hell’s going to employ the same logical fallacy in running in Florida on the 31st.
Ultimately, Romney has been too moderate and establishment for the Tea Party wing-nuts, and his Mormonism isn’t helping with the evangelicals. Even should he get the nomination, which is likely, he’ll still have a problem unraveling the damage that his own primary opponents have done in painting him as a member of the rich, corporate plutocracy. It’s likely to play poorly among the sought-after Independent voters. Still, congressional Republicans and their delegates are likely to support Romney as the most plausible nominee for the general election. Rick Santorum and Ron Paul lack the necessary clout on Capitol Hill, and haven’t got the base anyway. Gingrich, as one Republican leader said, always has his “finger 6 inches from the self-destruct button,” and makes for an unpredictable investment for the party. Still, this kind of “lesser-evil” approach to the nomination is a far-cry from the transformative candidate they were hoping for a year ago.